Andrew Smith, Ahmad Elnahas, Timothy Jackson, Fayez Quereshy, Todd Penner, David Urbach, Allan Okrainec. Division of General Surgery, University Health Network, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON.
Obesity is a leading public health challenge. The laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (LRYGB) has emerged as an effective and durable treatment option. There is a learning curve associated with this advanced laparoscopic procedure. Previous studies indicate that this learning curve is within the range of 100 cases per surgeon. The aim of the current study is to describe the learning curve of LRYGB at a Bariatric Centre of Excellence by examining operative time and outcomes of three non-bariatric fellowship-trained advanced laparoscopic surgeons.
METHODS AND PROCEDURES
This retrospective cohort study employed a hospital-generated database that captured both elective and emergent bariatric procedures performed from November 16, 2009 to August 30th, 2013 at a single Ontario Bariatric Centre of Excellence. Patients who underwent an elective LRYGB by three non-bariatric fellowship-trained advanced laparoscopic surgeons were included in the study. Outcomes of interest included operative time and unexpected return to the operating room as captured in the database.
From November 16th, 2009 to August 30th, 2013, 734 elective LRYGB were performed. The first 100 cases per surgeon were analyzed and compared to subsequent cases. Mean operative time for the three surgeons decreased by over 15 minutes as experience with LRYGB increased (146 minutes versus 130.9 minutes; p<0.001). Unexpected return to the operating room decreased following the initial 100 cases, however this did not reach significance (4% unexpected return versus 2.08%; p<0.13). To further describe the institutional learning curve, the first 150 cases performed at our centre were analyzed and compared to the subsequent 584 cases performed. As an institution, the mean operative time decreased by over 20 minutes as experience with LRYGB increased (153.5 minutes versus 132.9 minutes; p<0.001). Similarly, unexpected return to the operating room decreased following the first 150 cases (5.33% unexpected return versus 2.23%; p<0.04).
LRYGB is a technically demanding procedure with an appreciable learning curve. Results from this single-centre retrospective cohort study demonstrate that as experience with this advanced laparoscopic procedure increases, operative time amongst surgeons, as well as within the institution, decreases. While the unexpected return to the operating room of this Bariatric Centre of Excellence decreased following the initial 150 cases, this small cohort study would suggest that there is a trend to decreased return to the operating room amongst individual surgeons following the initial 100 cases. Additional studies are required to further elucidate this learning curve both amongst individual surgeons as well as at the level of the institution itself.